
What does a personality profile help an organisation change?
- Big Five research helps explain differences in individual job performance. The commercial question is how organisations use that insight in development, coaching and work design. [1][2]
- A 2025 synthesis reports 4.3% of task-performance variance explained by the Big Five, compared with 6.7% for HEXACO, a six-factor model. [4]
- Personality can be stable and still change. People can also adapt their behaviour to a task without first changing their underlying traits. [6][9]
- A group profile can inform a discussion about culture. Understanding culture also requires attention to shared assumptions, everyday experience and how the organisation works. [10]
- For leaders, the practical question is what changes after the profile: an agreed working arrangement, a coaching action or a decision, followed by an assessment of the result.
The boardroom question
If an organisation invests in personality profiling, what should it expect to be different afterwards?
That is a reasonable question for a chief executive, a finance director or a manager protecting time for development. A programme may give people a useful language for discussing differences. The people taking part may value the experience. A board can recognise both benefits and still ask whether the investment has improved delivery, customer advocacy or profit.
The Big Five deserves a fair hearing. It is one of the most extensively researched models of personality. Its five broad dimensions are Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness and Neuroticism, often expressed in the opposite direction as Emotional Stability. The model places people on continuous scales. It does not require everyone to fit a personality type. 1 4
That distinction is explored in Trait versus type: why psychology abandoned the boxes.
When a profiling programme is proposed as an investment in performance, leaders need to know which decisions or working practices it is expected to influence and how its value will be assessed.
What the Big Five evidence actually measures
Much of the research examines associations between personality and individual performance. Researchers might compare a personality measure with task performance or supervisor ratings. Some studies follow applicants into employment; others study people already doing the work. 2 3
Conscientiousness has a consistent relationship with performance across many roles. In the revised estimates reported by Paul Sackett and colleagues, its corrected validity correlation was 0.21 overall and 0.25 for measures framed specifically around work. 2 3
The strength of these relationships varies with the role, the situation and the outcome being assessed. Other traits can also be relevant in particular settings. 1 3
A separate 2025 review by Jan Luca Pletzer and Loes Abrahams compared broad personality models. Its synthesis reported 4.3% of variance in task performance for the Big Five, compared with 6.7% for HEXACO, a six-factor model. These estimates use a different method from Sackett's corrected correlations and should not be treated as interchangeable. 4
These findings help explain how personality relates to performance in particular roles. For leaders evaluating a development programme, the next question is how those insights are used in everyday work and what difference the programme makes.
What changes in everyday work does a profiling programme support, and what evidence demonstrates its commercial value?
Stable tendencies, everyday choices
Personality often shows substantial continuity over time. Roberts and DelVecchio's review of 152 longitudinal studies found that rank-order consistency generally increased into adulthood. Rank-order consistency describes how people's relative positions compare over time; it does not mean each person's scores are permanently fixed. 5
It is also important to distinguish stability from reliability. A reliable instrument should be capable of detecting real change. A changed score is not automatically evidence that the instrument has failed.
Roberts and colleagues' later review identified 207 studies tracking personality during interventions, primarily in clinical settings, and found changes in measured traits. A subsequent randomised study involving 1,523 participants also found changes in desired directions following a three-month digital intervention in a nonclinical population. 6 7
People also make choices about how to act in a particular situation. Brian Little's work on free traits describes acting beyond a usual tendency to pursue something that matters. A person who generally prefers quiet reflection may choose to be visibly outgoing when welcoming a new colleague. The practical question includes how sustainable that effort feels and what helps the person recover. 9
Context matters in another way. Pierce and Aguinis describe how apparently beneficial qualities can have limits, with their effects depending on circumstances. Careful preparation, for example, may support a complex decision; continued checking after the decision is ready may delay delivery. That is an illustration of the management question, not a diagnosis of conscientious people. 8
For a manager, this creates room for a useful conversation. What does this task require? How would the person prefer to approach it? Where would a different approach help, and what support would make that approach workable?
What would count as evidence for profit or EBITDA?
The research reviewed here does not establish that introducing a Big Five profiling programme causes higher operating profit, EBITDA or company valuation. That commercial claim needs evidence about the programme and the outcome in question. 2 3 4
The distance between an individual profile and a company result matters. Pricing, demand, costs and other organisational decisions can change at the same time as a development programme. If profit rises afterwards, the timing alone cannot tell us how much the programme contributed.
A useful evaluation follows the proposed route to improvement. Suppose a management team uses a profiling discussion to change how decisions are prepared. They agree which information is needed, who decides and when the decision is due. They can then examine decision time, rework and the quality of the resulting decisions. A finance discussion can consider whether those changes produced a measurable benefit, and at what cost.
An evaluation can also recognise benefits that matter to the people involved, such as finding it easier to discuss what they need.
For valuation claims, leaders would need evidence connecting the programme to sustained changes in business performance, with other influences on valuation taken into account.
Does personality profiling improve NPS?
Net Promoter Score concerns customers' willingness to recommend an organisation. It is a different outcome from an employee's personality score or a supervisor's performance rating. Evidence about one should not be presented as evidence about the other.
Consider a customer-service example. An agent is attentive, prepared and keen to help, but cannot resolve a billing problem because the organisation requires an approval that is unavailable. Understanding how the agent prefers to prepare or receive coaching may be useful. The approval process still needs attention.
If a programme is intended to improve customer advocacy, the evaluation should examine the customer's experience and NPS directly. It should also consider what changed in the service: the agent's actions, access to information, the resolution process, or some combination.
For contact centres, this connects with how often agents should be coached and what the evidence supports. The useful next step is an agreed action related to the work, followed by an opportunity to review what happened.
The test for the programme is whether it changed something that mattered to the customer.
Why a group profile is not a complete culture diagnosis
A group profile can make differences and concentrations visible. It can support a discussion about whose perspective is represented and how colleagues approach their work.
Organisational culture asks a further set of questions. Schneider, Ehrhart and Macey distinguish culture's shared assumptions and values from the meanings people attach to their experiences at work. Neither can be established simply by calculating an average personality score. 10
Imagine a leadership team whose members describe themselves as open to ideas. If colleagues repeatedly see uncomfortable information ignored, their experience of speaking up may differ from the leadership profile. Both pieces of information deserve attention. The profile cannot settle what happens in practice.
Aggregation is not automatically invalid. What matters is the question being asked, the model being used and whether the evidence supports the interpretation. A map of preferences can contribute to an enquiry into culture while leaders also examine decisions, incentives, everyday behaviour and colleagues' experiences.
That is the practical question behind why we measure culture so rarely. A useful map helps people investigate the organisation; it should not end the investigation.
Where work preferences become useful
The Big Five can provide a thoughtful basis for personal reflection. Work-preference tools address a related practical question: how does a person prefer to approach the work in front of them?
In Sariio, that means making preferences available for discussion around preparation, information, decisions, collaboration and delivery. What are work preferences? explains the distinction. Preferences describe how someone would prefer to work; they do not define that person's capability.
For example, one colleague may want a written outline before discussing a proposal. Another may develop ideas through conversation. The useful outcome could be an outline circulated in advance, followed by a discussion where both people can contribute. The team can then review whether that arrangement helped.
A myMAP can help a person describe their preferences. Colleagues can compare their maps by mutual choice and explore where a different working arrangement might help. At team or organisational level, the distribution of preferences can inform questions about how work is organised.
These are practical uses of insight. Their value still depends on what people agree, what changes and what happens afterwards. The same standard of evidence should apply to a preference tool as to a personality assessment.
The AI paradox: making work human-centric considers a related possibility: using technology to prepare for a conversation while preserving the person's choices and the manager's attention.
What should change after the profile?
Before choosing any assessment-led programme, a leadership team can make its commercial question concrete.
- Name the work that needs attention. For example, reducing repeated work, improving the handover between teams or helping managers prepare for a particular coaching conversation.
- Describe the action the insight is expected to support. Agree what people will do differently and what resources or authority they need.
- Choose measures close to that action. Record the starting position and review the experience with the people involved.
- Use a comparison where practical. A staggered introduction or a comparable team may help distinguish the programme's contribution from other changes.
- Review costs and outcomes together. Include the time required, implementation costs and what was learned before making a claim about return.
Sariio is the work preference layer that helps connect strategy with everyday work. It shows how each person prefers to work and how those preferences come together across teams and the organisation. Considered alongside stated values and people's experience, that shared understanding can also inform conversations about culture.
People at every level can use that insight to communicate, coach, lead and make decisions. A manager and colleague might agree how to approach a coaching conversation; a leadership team might change how it prepares for a decision. They can then review how those changes support the organisation's goals.
That is the practical ambition behind Sariio's purpose: "We do our best work when we can play to our preferences." Creating that opportunity means involving people in how work gets done, and learning from the results.
Sources and citations
- Barrick, M. R. & Mount, M. K. (1991). The Big Five personality dimensions and job performance: a meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 44(1), 1–26. Foundational evidence on traits, roles and performance criteria.
- Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M. & Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection: addressing systematic overcorrection for restriction of range. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040–2068.
- Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M. & Lievens, F. (2023). Revisiting the design of selection systems in light of new findings regarding the validity of widely used predictors. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 16(3), 283–300. Table 1 reproduces the conscientiousness estimates of 0.21 and 0.25.
- Pletzer, J. L. & Abrahams, L. (2025). Personality and job performance: a review of trait models and recent trends. Current Opinion in Psychology, 65, 102054. The Big Five and HEXACO task-performance figures are 4.3% and 6.7%, respectively. Open-access full paper.
- Roberts, B. W. & DelVecchio, W. F. (2000). The rank-order consistency of personality traits from childhood to old age: a quantitative review of longitudinal studies. Psychological Bulletin, 126(1), 3–25. Review of 152 longitudinal studies.
- Roberts, B. W., Luo, J., Briley, D. A., Chow, P. I., Su, R. & Hill, P. L. (2017). A systematic review of personality trait change through intervention. Psychological Bulletin, 143(2), 117–141. Review of 207 studies, primarily clinical interventions.
- Stieger, M. et al. (2021). Changing personality traits with the help of a digital personality change intervention. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(8), e2017548118. Randomised study involving 1,523 participants. Open-access full paper.
- Pierce, J. R. & Aguinis, H. (2013). The too-much-of-a-good-thing effect in management. Journal of Management, 39(2), 313–338. Context-dependent limits to apparently beneficial qualities.
- Little, B. R. (2008). Personal projects and free traits: personality and motivation reconsidered. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2(3), 1235–1254.
- Schneider, B., Ehrhart, M. G. & Macey, W. H. (2013). Organizational climate and culture. Annual Review of Psychology, 64, 361–388. Definitions, levels of analysis and organisational evidence.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Big Five predict job performance?
Some Big Five traits are associated with individual job performance. Conscientiousness is a consistent predictor across many roles, while other relationships depend on the work and the outcome being measured. The relevance of a profile therefore depends on the role, the measure used and the decisions it is intended to inform.
Does personality profiling improve EBITDA, profit or NPS?
The job-performance studies reviewed here examine personality and individual performance. To assess a profiling programme's commercial value, an organisation needs evidence of its effect on working practices and the relevant business measures, together with the full cost of implementation and the influence of other changes over the same period.
Can personality traits change?
Yes. Personality often shows substantial continuity, but stability does not mean permanence. Research has documented changes during interventions, including a randomised study of a digital programme in a nonclinical population. Reliable measures can capture changes in traits over time; the type of intervention and the population studied help explain the findings.
How are work preferences different from personality traits?
Personality traits describe broad tendencies in how people think, feel and behave. Work preferences describe how someone prefers to approach aspects of work, such as preparation, decisions, collaboration and delivery. The concepts can overlap. A preference discussion becomes practically useful when people agree how to apply the insight to a particular task and review the result.
Can you measure organisational culture by averaging personality scores?
An average can describe the measured traits of a group, but it does not establish the shared assumptions, norms or experiences that make up organisational culture. A group profile can contribute to an enquiry. It needs to be considered alongside what people experience, what leaders reward and how decisions are made in practice.
Sources: 10.
How should an organisation assess the value of a profiling programme?
Start with a specific work problem and agree what improvement would look like. Record a baseline, describe the change the programme is intended to support and choose measures close to that change. Use a suitable comparison where practical, record other relevant changes and include the full cost before drawing conclusions about commercial value.